Dick Rosenthal {l Wrote}:If you go back in this thread you will see that I acknowledge Schmidt's short comings from a tactical perspective and I think the Al analogy is pretty fair (given they were both A-10 Coach of the Year). Schmidt's strength is two-fold: (1) He is very good at recognizing diamond's in the rough and developing them and (2) on the rare occasions where he goes toe-to-toe with big P5 programs he has a surprising level of success (Nelson Kaputo and Matt Mobely transfer, Demeitius Conger, Marquise Simmons and Da'quan Cook).
My only point is that we cheaped out when we hired Christian--a guy who had failed miserably during his only foray into a P5 conference. If we were going to go cheap, we could have had Schmidt which would likely have avoided the current embarrassing shit show.
Your arguments just aren't making any sense. Again, let me reiterate, I don't know if there would have been a difference had Schmidt been hired over Christian, I think its impossible to say one would have been better than the other, but to say that BC "cheaped out" on Christian, when your argument above was that they could have gotten Schmidt "dirt cheap", doesn't really add up. You're making these arguments, that he would have been a better hire, based on him being an alum, thats basically it.
As for the past performance argument, a few things. JC has had a much greater history of success over his career, numbers don't lie. I assume you are referring to his time at TCU when you say he "failed miserably during his only foray into a P5 conference" (even tho TCU was in the Mountain West at the time), but you fail to realize that he built that program (an afterthought of a program) to an 18 win team in year 4, taking over a less than ideal situation.
Your other point, that Schmidt has done a good job getting JUCOs and transfers, but you fail to realize that this is one of the worst places to try and implement that strategy (JUCO's aren't admitted here). Did JC miss on Carter ? Yes. He took a guy and expected him to play out of position, at the most important position on the court. Did he get good grad transfers last year in Brown and Batten, yea, they worked out ok. Trying to say Schmidt has an advantage in identifying players that could never play here, is just another reason why he probably couldn't see similar success at BC.
Basketball isn't rocket science. I would argue that even more than football, it really just comes down to who you can recruit and the bodies you have on campus. There are very few "systems" that can hide deficienceis, basketball is a fairly transparent game from an X's and O's perspective. To try and make an argument that one mid-major coach would be better than another is just crazy, and in this case, is totally unwarranted. If you want Schmidt just because he was an alum, thats fine, just say that, but to try and make an argument that he would have had more success than JC is just nuts at this point.