hansen {l Wrote}:I'm waiting for Rosenthal to weigh in on the Fighting AngryDick's performance yesterday.
Sorry, was in Captiva enjoying a mixed bag of SW Florida weather. I expected Notre Dame to lose, so I was not particularly upset with the outcome and very much enjoyed the cover.
In terms of my assessment of Notre Dame, it is pretty much in line with what McShay said at the end of the game and has further stated in interviews since then. Notre Dame has improved enormously since there appearance in the 2012 BCS Championship (although the irony is that if Kansas State doesn't shit the bed against Baylor and Oregon doesn't shank the FG against Stanford, there is a better than 50% chance that deeply flawed Notre Dame team beats one of those two teams for the MNC while one-loss Bama is relegated to pounding the crap out of someone in the Sugar Bowl). Notre Dame can now match up from an interior perspective with Alabama, Ohio State and Clemson (O-line/TEs and front seven) which was not the case at all in 2012 (the gap was closing in 2018, but not all the way there). The problem is that there is still a gaping chasm in terms of WRs, DBs and QBs (Notre Dame has done pretty well with RBs). Notre Dame occasionally fields an elite college DB or WR (Kyle Hamilton, Julian Love, Miles Boykin or Chase Claypool), but with the exception of Hamilton, all of the aforementioned guys were 3 stars who exceeded expectations and they have missed badly on elite recruits in those positions. The DB situation was allegedly a product of Todd Lyght being a good teacher but a horrible recruiter. It will be interesting to see if Mike Mickens can substantially improve the recruiting without a dramatic fall of in development. The early verdict is not great as the 2021 class for DBs is chock full of 3 stars, with one 4 star and zero 5 stars. A lot of criticism has been leveled at WR Coach Del Alexander both for recruiting and development. They landed a couple of 4 stars this class--Lorenzo Styles was a big win over in-state tOSU--but they whiffed on a couple of 5 star targets and some guys who were 4 stars coming in a couple of years ago have not lived up to expectations (Kevin Austin and Braden Lenzy). QB is probably the biggest hurdle, as every QB Notre Dame has had has regressed under Kelly and the only QBs who have been able to start over multiple years during the Kelly era were extremely limited 3 star players--Book and Rees--while the list of highly regarded 4 star and 5 star recruits who fell apart under Kelly's tutelage is lengthy (Crist, Kiel, Zaire, Wimbush, Kizer, Jurk). Tyler Buchner is allegedly the best QB Kelly has landed (although Kiel was a consensus 5 star, so I am not sure how Buchner--a high 4 star--can be better). It will be interesting to see if he develops.