Mike_S {l Wrote}:I didn't realize Daz was on the coaches channel and was just watching the main broadcast. Amazed by the comments in this thread about how good/insightful he was during much of the game. I read his post-game comments and can't understand what he's trying to say -- they mostly make no sense at all!!
Also: While I'm glad Clemson won it, the last play leaves me a little sour. Watson held the ball a bit long for the situation, meaning that if the play failed, it likely would have run out the clock and not left time for a field goal. Meanwhile they also got away with a pretty obvious pick on the play. If I remember correctly, ND lost a game in the last year or two (either vs. Clemson or FSU) with a similar play at the end when the refs called it. I know the refs usually swallow their whistle at the end, but if they called it there either Clemson loses or at best gets it to OT.
Finally: I think Alabama hurt themselves a lot by going with the pass on their second-to-last possession leading by three with about 7 minutes to go. Clemson's defense was tiring, and they threw on both second and third down resulting in no first down and leaving 6 minutes left on the clock. Given the strength of their interior line, I felt like power or QB running (at least on second down) would have resulted in a better chance at the first down and running the clock down. A few first downs right there would have put Clemson in a lot of trouble and kept their own defense a little fresher for the end of the game.
Tremendous fourth quarter though, and great win for Clemson. Their receivers were incredible late in the game.
There's a few articles out there today discussing the illegal pick rule and whether Clemson "got away with it" last night.
General consensus:
1) First TD pick not at all illegal. The Clemson player turned around and squared up as a receiver before the ball was thrown. Even though he was clearly picking, this act of turning around means that his intention is to be a receiver, therefore because contact is allowed within first 5 yards it's legal.
2) Final TD also clearly a pick, but apparently from better replay angles you can see that the Clemson player fell down in front of the Alabama defender and the defender lost his balance trying to get around him. Either way, there was no contact apparently which also means it wasn't technically illegal.
Both plays were grey areas under the rules where the refs certainly could've thrown a flag based on a judgement call. Basically, both clearly picks, but neither clearly an illegal pick.
Also, saw an article comparing directly to that ND call a few years ago. Apparently on that play the ND receiver initiated contact, blocked, and never showed any intention to act as a receiver. No grey area there. That's the definition of an illegal pick.