DomingoOrtiz {l Wrote}:Ok, but the point I wanted to make is that he has over recruited some positions (WR) and under recruited others (DT) to the detriment of the program.
2014: 4 WRs (Flutie, Thad "Chad" Smith, Dixon, McClary); 2 DTs (Stevens, Merritt).
2015: 5 WRs (Jeff Smith, Walker, Glines, Borgersen, Pankey); 1 DT (Ray Smith)
2016: 2 WRs (White, McStravick); 1 DT (Korutz).
I think most agree he's done fine on evaluation. And while you said Fail, I think most (if they were viewing this objectively) would agree that he has done a good job landing the kids he's gone after. Again, talent isn't the issue with this team.
However, as you rightfully have pointed out, he has failed miserably in the over all management of recruiting. You point out his busted numbers by position. I'd point out that he hasn't recruited to match a vision. Wide body vs agile OL... drop-back vs mobile QB... big athletic vs small and quick WRs... we haven't made any preference clear. It's like he's trying to build a fantasy FB team where you only care about stats.
Ultimately, none of this should surprise. The more intellectually challenging a task, the worse our Gym Teacher performs.
Can we rename this Smiley Daz?