by eagle216 on Wed Dec 03, 2014 3:02 pm
I was just cleaning up my DVR and stopped to replay the Bordner pass play a few times (the one during the last drive). A couple of observations I did not notice initially, and that I don't believe have been discussed on this content-driven site.
1) Even if Murphy "catches" the pass, it almost certainly is dislodged by the second FSU tackler. Murphy high-points the ball (thanks Mike Mayock), and the ball bounces off his hands. But the second tackler comes in with his arms and shoulder and absolutely would have blown it up had Murphy secured the ball and attempted to bring it down. I just don't see how he would retain possession - and no, it would never have been ruled a catch and fumble.
2) Bordner had a receiver (or back) open on a post. He may have had to pump fake to Murphy to make it work, though. They ran someone (couldn't catch the number) on a post to try to occupy the safety. The safety made a nice read and went to the corner very quickly, leaving the post wide open. Its hard to say if the safety committed only after seeing Bordner turn and start his throwing motion towards Murphy, or whether he just went there independent of Bordner. Nonetheless, when that play is taught, I am fairly certain that Bordner is told to either throw it to Murphy or tuck in run. He probably is not instructed to work progressions. But had he looked off Murphy, he had a much better option on the post, and an absolute pitch and catch if he had the instinct to pump fake Murphy. He certainly had the time.
3) The last successful running play prior to the Bordner pass - I had no idea, live, how close that was to 6. A lesser talent than the FSU DB there, and Outlow probably takes that to the house.
4) Watching that last drive 2 weeks later, it seems more like a good call (the Bordner pass) now. They stuffed the 1st down run, and I just think with the shortened field, we needed to do something at that point other than run it. Maybe not a trick play, but a pass was absolutely the correct call. As far as trick plays, maybe a flea flicker with Alston on a wheel route, and someone else on a post, but who knows if that is even in the playbook.